Optimisation of a geometric quantity: boxes, rectangles, cylinders, cones and distances
Question 1
A window is a rectangle of width and height surmounted by a semicircle, with total perimeter m. A student writes:
Line 1: the semicircle has radius , so its arc is
Line 2: perimeter:
Line 3: area
Line 4: eliminate using Line 2 and maximise
Where does the working first go wrong?
(a)Line 2
(b)Line 1
(c)Nothing is wrong
(d)Line 3
Show answer
(a) Line 2
Line 1 is correct. Line 2 is the first wrong line: the top of the rectangle is the diameter of the semicircle and lies inside the window, so it is not part of the perimeter. The constraint is . Lines 3 and 4 describe the right method but rest on the wrong constraint.
The derivative as the rate of change of one quantity with respect to another
Question 2
To find the rate of change of the area of a circle with respect to its radius at cm, a student writes:
Line 1:
Line 2: at ,
Line 3:
Line 4: so the area is not changing at
Where does the working first go wrong?
(a)Nothing is wrong
(b)Line 2
(c)Line 3
(d)Line 4
Show answer
(c) Line 3
Lines 1 and 2 are both true statements: the rule is right and the area really is when . Line 3 is the first wrong line -- it differentiates a number. The rate must come from differentiating the rule while is a variable, giving , and only then substituting: the rate is , not .
Two quantities changing with time: related rates through the Chain Rule
Question 3
On the curve , increases at units per second. Find the rate of change of the slope at . A student writes:
Line 1:
Line 2:
Line 3: at ,
Line 4: so the slope is changing at units per second
Where does the working first go wrong?
(a)Nothing is wrong
(b)Line 4
(c)Line 3
(d)Line 2
Show answer
(b) Line 4
Lines 1 to 3 are all true: they compute , the rate at which changes. Line 4 is the first wrong line -- it reports that as the rate of the slope. The slope is , and at .
Two rates linked through a third: eliminating the intermediate rate
Question 4
A spherical ball of ice melts so that the rate of decrease of its volume is proportional to its surface area. What follows for its radius?
(a)The radius decreases at a constant rate
(b)The radius does not change, because the two rates cancel
(c)The radius decreases at exactly unit per second
(d)The radius decreases at a rate proportional to
Show answer
(a) The radius decreases at a constant rate
Write with . But gives , so and : the radius decreases at a constant rate. Its size is , whatever is -- not necessarily 1; and the two rates do not cancel, they are the same rate written two ways.
Finding the intervals on which a function increases or decreases
Question 5
To find where is increasing, a student writes:
Line 1:
Line 2: at and
Line 3: on and on ; on
Line 4: so is increasing on
Where does the working first go wrong?
(a)Line 4
(b)Nothing is wrong
(c)Line 3
(d)Line 2
Show answer
(a) Line 4
Lines 1 to 3 are correct. Line 4 is the first wrong line: is increasing on each of the two intervals separately, but not on their union, because it decreases on in between -- a point of the left piece can be higher than a point of the right piece. The answer must be stated as two intervals.
Functions with a gap in the domain: increasing on each piece, not across the gap
Question 6
For one finds that is increasing exactly where . Which set is this?
(a) and
(b) only
(c) only
(d)
Show answer
(a) and
means or : the two outer rays and , everything outside the middle interval . Reading it as the middle interval reverses the set; keeping only one ray loses half of it.
Increasing and decreasing on a bounded interval: the trigonometric cases
Question 7
To find the intervals on which , , is increasing or decreasing, one solves , which reduces to . Which are all the solutions in ?
(a), and
(b) and
(c) only
(d) and
Show answer
(d) and
A trigonometric equation has a solution in every period, and the interval is long enough to contain more than the principal one; every solution inside is a cut point. Solutions beyond the end of do not belong: the given interval bounds the analysis.
Finding the values of a parameter for which a function is increasing or decreasing
Question 8
Let . What is the complete set of values of for which for every real ?
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
Show answer
(b)
The largest value of occurs at . It must be negative, giving . Checking the smallest derivative value instead gives . Replacing the trigonometric term by zero gives .
Increasing and decreasing functions, and the sign of the derivative
Question 9
Assertion (A): is increasing on .
Reason (R): for all .
Which of the following is correct?
(a)A is false
(b)A is true but R is false
(c)Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A
(d)Both A and R are true but R is not the correct explanation of A
Show answer
(b) A is true but R is false
A is true: for one has , and with a single zero confirms it. R is false as stated: at , , so is not positive for all . A true assertion can have a false reason, because increasing does not require everywhere; and the zero of does not make A false.
Local maxima and minima, and the critical points where they can occur
Question 10
For , , one finds a local maximum at with value and a local minimum at with value . Can this be right, given that ?
(a)No: a local maximum value must exceed every local minimum value, so one of the two must have the wrong label
(b)Yes: each is an extremum only relative to the values near it, and the two neighbourhoods are far apart
(c)No: and make both points extrema of the same kind
(d)Yes, but only because is not defined at ; for a function defined on all of it could not happen
Show answer
(b) Yes: each is an extremum only relative to the values near it, and the two neighbourhoods are far apart
Yes. 'Local' means largest or smallest among nearby values only. Near every value of is at most , and near every value is at least ; the two neighbourhoods lie on opposite sides of the gap at , so the values need not compare the way the words suggest. A local maximum can be smaller than a local minimum.
The first derivative test: reading the sign change of $f'$ through a critical point
Question 11
For , .
Assertion (A): has no local extremum at .
Reason (R): .
Which of the following is correct?
(a)A is false, because alternates in sign at every one of its zeros
(b)Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
(c)A is false, because is itself enough for a local extremum
(d)Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
Show answer
(d) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
A is true: the squared factor keeps negative on both sides of , so there is no sign change and no extremum. R is true as a computation. But R does not explain A -- is exactly what makes a candidate; the reason there is no extremum is the absence of a sign change. So both are true and R is not the correct explanation of A.
The second derivative test, and what to do when it fails
Question 12
To find the maximum value of , a student writes:
Line 1:
Line 2: gives
Line 3: a negative value of is not meaningful, so it is rejected
Line 4: hence has no maximum value
Where does the working first go wrong?
(a)Line 4
(b)Line 2
(c)Nothing is wrong
(d)Line 3
Show answer
(d) Line 3
Lines 1 and 2 are correct. Line 3 is the first wrong line: is simply the variable of the given function and nothing restricts it to positive values, so is a legitimate critical point. With it is a maximum, value ; Line 4 is false.
Absolute maximum and minimum values on a closed interval
Question 13
The figure shows the graph of a function on a closed interval. The graph passes through the points , , , and . and are the two end points of the interval. How many local minima does have?
(a), the absolute minimum only
(b)
(c)
(d)
Show answer
(d)
A local minimum is an interior point lower than its neighbours on both sides -- a valley. The graph has two valleys, so two local minima, even though only one of them is the absolute minimum. End points are not local extrema.
Maximum and minimum values of a function, and when they do not exist
Question 14
Find the maximum and minimum values, if any, of .
(a)Minimum value ; no maximum value
(b)Minimum value , and a maximum value at the ends of the domain
(c)Minimum value ; no maximum value
(d)No maximum and no minimum, since has neither
Show answer
(c) Minimum value ; no maximum value
with equality at , so has a minimum value at the corner . On the other side grows without bound, so can be made as large as we please and has no maximum value. The inner expression has no bound at all, but the modulus supplies one end; and the corner's -coordinate is not the value there.
Optimisation: two numbers with a fixed sum, and cost, revenue and profit
Question 15
To find two positive numbers with sum whose sum of the squares is a minimum, a student writes:
Line 1: let the numbers be and , with
Line 2: the sum of the squares is
Line 3: is found by treating as a constant
Line 4: so has no critical point and no minimum
Where does the working first go wrong?
(a)Line 3
(b)Line 4
(c)Line 2
(d)Nothing is wrong
Show answer
(a) Line 3
Lines 1 and 2 are correct. Line 3 is the first wrong line: is not a constant -- it is -- and the constraint must be used to write before differentiating. Then at and Line 4 is false.
Common misconception in Application of Derivatives
Does a zero derivative guarantee a maximum or minimum?
Wrong
Every point where f′(x) = 0 is a turning point.
Why it feels right. Smooth maxima and minima often have horizontal tangents.
Right
A stationary point can have a horizontal tangent while the function keeps increasing through it.
Worked example
The curve flattens at zero but rises on both sides. There is no local maximum or minimum there.
For f(x) = x³, f′(0) = 0.
Values go from −1 at x = −1 to 0 to 1 at x = 1, and the function increases throughout.
Cookies
We use cookies, including Meta’s and, if a ChatGPT advert brought
you, OpenAI’s, to see how visitors find us.
They are never used on your child’s screens in the app. You can turn them
off here, and change your mind any time.
Privacy policy